A fn def'd into a var reports a JVM-style class name (clojure.core$odd_QMARK_)

jolt fns reported (class f) = clojure.lang.IFn, so they carried no defining
symbol — clojure.spec.alpha's fn-sym (which reads a fn's class name to recover its
symbol) produced garbage, so explain-data's :pred for a bare-fn predicate was `/`
instead of e.g. clojure.core/keyword?.

Now def-var! records proc -> (ns . name) (first def of a proc wins, so an alias
like (def inc' inc) doesn't rename inc), and jolt-class-name returns "ns$munged"
for a known fn — matching the JVM, where (class odd?) is clojure.core$odd_QMARK_.
A munged fn class's ancestors include clojure.lang.AFunction's hierarchy
(IFn/AFn/Fn/Runnable/Callable), so (ancestors (class f)) still holds. Anonymous /
unregistered fns stay clojure.lang.IFn (fn-sym yields :unknown, as on the JVM).

This fixes explain-data / s/form / s/describe of bare-fn predicates in
clojure.spec.alpha (and unblocks parts of its suite + test.check's reporter test).

make test green (+1 corpus row, the (type inc) unit row updated to the JVM value),
shakesmoke byte-identical, runtime only (no re-mint).
This commit is contained in:
Yogthos 2026-06-27 21:03:12 -04:00
parent 10592fa746
commit 0becba7f93
5 changed files with 43 additions and 4 deletions

View file

@ -62,6 +62,26 @@
(lambda (x) (if (string=? (chez-condition-exc-class x) "ArityException") (lambda (x) (if (string=? (chez-condition-exc-class x) "ArityException")
"clojure.lang.ArityException" "clojure.lang.ArityException"
"java.lang.IllegalArgumentException"))) "java.lang.IllegalArgumentException")))
;; A fn def'd into a var reports a JVM-style class name "ns$munged-name" (the
;; forward CHAR_MAP), so clojure.spec.alpha's fn-sym (which splits on $ and
;; demunges) recovers the predicate's symbol. Anonymous / unregistered fns stay
;; clojure.lang.IFn (fn-sym yields :unknown, as on the JVM).
(define class-munge-map
'((#\? . "_QMARK_") (#\! . "_BANG_") (#\* . "_STAR_") (#\+ . "_PLUS_")
(#\> . "_GT_") (#\< . "_LT_") (#\= . "_EQ_") (#\/ . "_SLASH_") (#\- . "_")
(#\& . "_AMPERSAND_") (#\% . "_PERCENT_") (#\~ . "_TILDE_") (#\^ . "_CARET_")
(#\| . "_BAR_") (#\: . "_COLON_")))
(define (class-munge-name s)
(let ((out (open-output-string)))
(string-for-each
(lambda (c) (let ((t (assv c class-munge-map))) (if t (display (cdr t) out) (write-char c out))))
s)
(get-output-string out)))
(register-class-arm!
(lambda (x) (and (procedure? x) (hashtable-ref proc-name-tbl x #f)))
(lambda (x) (let ((p (hashtable-ref proc-name-tbl x #f)))
(string-append (car p) "$" (class-munge-name (cdr p))))))
(define (jolt-class-name x) (define (jolt-class-name x)
(let loop ((as jolt-class-arms)) (let loop ((as jolt-class-arms))
(cond ((null? as) (jolt-class-base x)) (cond ((null? as) (jolt-class-base x))

View file

@ -953,12 +953,21 @@
(reg-class-supers! "clojure.lang.LazySeq" '("clojure.lang.ISeq" "clojure.lang.IPersistentCollection" "clojure.lang.Sequential" "clojure.lang.Seqable" "java.lang.Iterable")) (reg-class-supers! "clojure.lang.LazySeq" '("clojure.lang.ISeq" "clojure.lang.IPersistentCollection" "clojure.lang.Sequential" "clojure.lang.Seqable" "java.lang.Iterable"))
(reg-class-supers! "clojure.lang.Cons" '("clojure.lang.ASeq" "clojure.lang.ISeq" "clojure.lang.Sequential" "clojure.lang.Seqable" "java.lang.Iterable")) (reg-class-supers! "clojure.lang.Cons" '("clojure.lang.ASeq" "clojure.lang.ISeq" "clojure.lang.Sequential" "clojure.lang.Seqable" "java.lang.Iterable"))
;; A munged fn class name "ns$name" (jolt-class for a def'd fn) isn't in the table;
;; like the JVM (a fn extends clojure.lang.AFunction) its super is AFunction, whose
;; registered supers give AFn / IFn / Fn / Runnable / Callable transitively.
(define (str-has-dollar? s)
(let loop ((i 0)) (and (< i (string-length s)) (or (char=? (string-ref s i) #\$) (loop (+ i 1))))))
(define (class-direct-supers name)
(or (hashtable-ref class-supers-tbl name #f)
(and (str-has-dollar? name) '("clojure.lang.AFunction"))
'()))
;; transitive closure of direct supers (set semantics via an accumulator list) ;; transitive closure of direct supers (set semantics via an accumulator list)
(define (class-ancestors-list name) (define (class-ancestors-list name)
(let loop ((pending (hashtable-ref class-supers-tbl name '())) (seen '())) (let loop ((pending (class-direct-supers name)) (seen '()))
(cond ((null? pending) (reverse seen)) (cond ((null? pending) (reverse seen))
((member (car pending) seen) (loop (cdr pending) seen)) ((member (car pending) seen) (loop (cdr pending) seen))
(else (loop (append (hashtable-ref class-supers-tbl (car pending) '()) (cdr pending)) (else (loop (append (class-direct-supers (car pending)) (cdr pending))
(cons (car pending) seen)))))) (cons (car pending) seen))))))
;; (instance? Class e) on a throwable tagged-table carrying a JVM :class matches the ;; (instance? Class e) on a throwable tagged-table carrying a JVM :class matches the

View file

@ -114,7 +114,16 @@
;; evaluates to #'ns/name (a first-class var), so (var? (def x 1)) is true and ;; evaluates to #'ns/name (a first-class var), so (var? (def x 1)) is true and
;; (pr-str (def x 1)) is "#'ns/x". The prelude's def-var! forms discard the ;; (pr-str (def x 1)) is "#'ns/x". The prelude's def-var! forms discard the
;; return, so this is transparent there. ;; return, so this is transparent there.
(define (def-var! ns name v) (let ((c (jolt-var ns name))) (var-cell-root-set! c v) (var-cell-defined?-set! c #t) c)) ;; proc -> (ns . name) for the var it was def'd into, so (class a-fn) can report a
;; JVM-style class name and clojure.spec.alpha's fn-sym can recover the symbol of a
;; bare-fn predicate. Weak so GC'd fns drop out. Last def of a given proc wins.
(define proc-name-tbl (make-weak-eq-hashtable))
(define (def-var! ns name v)
;; first def of a given proc wins, so an alias like (def inc' inc) — which binds
;; the SAME proc to a second var — doesn't rename inc.
(when (and (procedure? v) (not (hashtable-contains? proc-name-tbl v)))
(hashtable-set! proc-name-tbl v (cons ns name)))
(let ((c (jolt-var ns name))) (var-cell-root-set! c v) (var-cell-defined?-set! c #t) c))
;; jolt.host/throwable — build a typed throwable a library can throw so (class …), ;; jolt.host/throwable — build a typed throwable a library can throw so (class …),
;; instance?, .getMessage and ex-message all reflect the named JVM class (e.g. an ;; instance?, .getMessage and ex-message all reflect the named JVM class (e.g. an
;; http client throwing java.net.ConnectException). Strictly better than a ;; http client throwing java.net.ConnectException). Strictly better than a

View file

@ -3387,5 +3387,6 @@
{:suite "host-interop / UUID + Long + shiftLeft" :label "(UUID. msb lsb), .shiftLeft, (Long. n)" :expected "[\"00000000-0000-007b-0000-0000000001c8\" 40 10 42]" :actual "[(str (java.util.UUID. 123 456)) (.shiftLeft 5 3) (.shiftRight 40 2) (Long. 42)]"} {:suite "host-interop / UUID + Long + shiftLeft" :label "(UUID. msb lsb), .shiftLeft, (Long. n)" :expected "[\"00000000-0000-007b-0000-0000000001c8\" 40 10 42]" :actual "[(str (java.util.UUID. 123 456)) (.shiftLeft 5 3) (.shiftRight 40 2) (Long. 42)]"}
{:suite "host-interop / ThreadLocal proxy" :label "(proxy [ThreadLocal] [] (initialValue [] v)) get/set" :expected "[42 7]" :actual "(let [tl (proxy [ThreadLocal] [] (initialValue [] 42))] [(.get tl) (do (.set tl 7) (.get tl))])"} {:suite "host-interop / ThreadLocal proxy" :label "(proxy [ThreadLocal] [] (initialValue [] v)) get/set" :expected "[42 7]" :actual "(let [tl (proxy [ThreadLocal] [] (initialValue [] 42))] [(.get tl) (do (.set tl 7) (.get tl))])"}
{:suite "host-interop / Compiler/demunge" :label "demunge reverses name munging" :expected "\"a/b?\"" :actual "(clojure.lang.Compiler/demunge \"a$b_QMARK_\")"} {:suite "host-interop / Compiler/demunge" :label "demunge reverses name munging" :expected "\"a/b?\"" :actual "(clojure.lang.Compiler/demunge \"a$b_QMARK_\")"}
{:suite "host-interop / a fn reports its munged class" :label "(class a-def'd-fn) is ns$munged-name, with the IFn hierarchy as ancestors" :expected "[\"clojure.core$odd_QMARK_\" true]" :actual "[(.getName (class odd?)) (boolean (some #{java.lang.Runnable} (ancestors (class odd?))))]"}
{:suite "host-interop / MultiFn methods" :label ".getMethod / .dispatchFn on a multimethod" :expected "[true true true]" :actual "(do (defmulti mmc identity) (defmethod mmc :a [_] 1) [(some? (.getMethod mmc :a)) (nil? (.getMethod mmc :z)) (ifn? (.dispatchFn mmc))])"} {:suite "host-interop / MultiFn methods" :label ".getMethod / .dispatchFn on a multimethod" :expected "[true true true]" :actual "(do (defmulti mmc identity) (defmethod mmc :a [_] 1) [(some? (.getMethod mmc :a)) (nil? (.getMethod mmc :z)) (ifn? (.dispatchFn mmc))])"}
] ]

View file

@ -479,7 +479,7 @@
{:suite "type" :expr "(type (filter odd? [1 2 3]))" :expected "clojure.lang.PersistentList"} {:suite "type" :expr "(type (filter odd? [1 2 3]))" :expected "clojure.lang.PersistentList"}
{:suite "type" :expr "(type (lazy-seq (cons 1 nil)))" :expected "clojure.lang.LazySeq"} {:suite "type" :expr "(type (lazy-seq (cons 1 nil)))" :expected "clojure.lang.LazySeq"}
{:suite "type" :expr "(type (take 2 (iterate inc 0)))" :expected "clojure.lang.PersistentList"} {:suite "type" :expr "(type (take 2 (iterate inc 0)))" :expected "clojure.lang.PersistentList"}
{:suite "type" :expr "(type inc)" :expected "clojure.lang.IFn"} {:suite "type" :expr "(type inc)" :expected "clojure.core$inc"}
{:suite "type" :expr "(type (sorted-map :a 1))" :expected ":map"} {:suite "type" :expr "(type (sorted-map :a 1))" :expected ":map"}
{:suite "type" :expr "(type (sorted-set 1))" :expected ":jolt/sorted-set"} {:suite "type" :expr "(type (sorted-set 1))" :expected ":jolt/sorted-set"}
{:suite "type" :expr "(type (with-meta [1] {:type :custom}))" :expected ":custom"} {:suite "type" :expr "(type (with-meta [1] {:type :custom}))" :expected ":custom"}