multi-arity fn*, nil sentinel in resolve-sym, let pre-registration, meta/when-not/qualified-symbol? core bindings

evaluator: fn* multi-arity dispatch, nil-local-vs-absent sentinel, let* pre-registers bindings
core: core-meta, core-when-not, core-qualified-symbol?, *unchecked-math*, *clojure-version*
This commit is contained in:
Yogthos 2026-06-01 23:37:55 -04:00
parent b20536d1e3
commit e1317c0a7e
6 changed files with 175 additions and 78 deletions

View file

@ -1,7 +1,6 @@
---
name: jolt-bootstrap
description: TDD workflow for bootstrapping a Clojure interpreter on Janet
---
# jolt-bootstrap
TDD workflow for bootstrapping a Clojure interpreter on Janet
# Bootstrapping a Clojure interpreter on Janet
@ -20,27 +19,34 @@ description: TDD workflow for bootstrapping a Clojure interpreter on Janet
## Current bootstrap progress
**Loaded (all .cljc, #? resolved at read time):**
- `sci.impl.macros` — 4/4 (ns, defmacro deftime, defmacro usetime, deftime(? macro))
- `sci.impl.protocols` — 15/17
- `sci.impl.utils` — 39/47
- `sci.impl.types` — 22/27
- `sci.impl.unrestrict` — 2/2
- `sci.impl.vars` — 28/28 (comment block parses via :jolt/skip sentinel)
- `sci.lang` — 10/10 (IVar resolves via class-name pattern lookup)
- `sci.ctx-store` — 6/6
- `sci.impl.namespaces` — 93/98 (parse crash at unmatched brace)
- `sci.core` — 60/69 (namespaces/*1/*2/*3/*e unresolved)
**All files parse cleanly. Eval status:**
**Special forms (22):** quote, syntax-quote, unquote, unquote-splicing, do, if, def, defmacro, fn*, let*, loop*, recur, throw, try, set!, var, locking, instance?, defmulti, defmethod, deftype, new, .
| File | Forms | Eval OK | Failures |
|------|-------|---------|----------|
| sci.impl.macros | 4/4 | 4 | 0 |
| sci.impl.protocols | 15/17 | 15 | 2 (resolution stubs) |
| sci.impl.utils | 39/47 | 39 | 8 (multi-arity, missing deps) |
| sci.impl.types | 22/27 | 22 | 5 (resolution stubs) |
| sci.impl.unrestrict | 2/2 | 2 | 0 |
| sci.impl.vars | 28/28 | 28 | 0 |
| sci.lang | 10/10 | 10 | 0 |
| sci.ctx-store | 6/6 | 6 | 0 |
| sci.impl.namespaces | 93/98 | 93 | 5 (missing copy-core-var dep) |
| sci.core | 60/69 | 60 | 4 (*1/*2/*3/*e unresolved) |
**Reader:** `#?(:clj ...)`, `#?@(:clj ...)` with splicing, `#_` discard (returns :jolt/skip sentinel), `#\` var-quote, `^` metadata. Comments `;` skip via :jolt/skip. Closing delimiters `)`, `]`, `}` produce explicit "Unmatched" errors.
**Loading order:** macros → protocols → types → unrestrict → vars(27/28, skip comment block) → lang → utils → ctx-store → namespaces → core
**Core macros:** when, defn (with docstring), defn-, declare, fn (wraps fn*), defprotocol, extend-type, extend-protocol, extend, reify, proxy, definterface, comment (ignores body), prefer-method (stub)
**Added special forms:** quote, syntax-quote, unquote, unquote-splicing, do, if, def, defmacro, fn*, let*, loop*, recur, throw, try, set!, var, locking, instance?, defmulti, defmethod, deftype, new, . (22 total)
**Key utilities:** `unwrap-meta-name` — recursively unwraps `(with-meta sym meta)` to extract raw symbol. Used in def, ns, deftype, defmethod.
**Core additions:** when (macro), defn (macro with docstring), declare (macro), fn (macro — wraps fn*), Object (interop stub), derive, isa?, ancestors, descendants (hierarchy stubs), defprotocol (macro), extend-type, extend-protocol (macro), extend (macro), reify, satisfies?, extends?, implements?, type->str, comment (macro), prefer-method (stub), *unchecked-math* (false), *clojure-version* ({:major 1 :minor 11})
**Class-name resolution:** unqualified symbols with dots (`Foo.Bar.Baz`) are resolved by splitting at last dot into ns+name.
**Reader:** `#?(:clj ...)`, `#?@(:clj ...)` with splicing, `#_` discard, `#\` var-quote, `^` metadata, `;` comments → skip, nil `#?(:cljs ...)` → skip (non-splicing), empty `#?@(:cljs ...)` → empty splice, unmatched `)]}` → explicit errors
## Current blockers
1. `sci.impl.copy-vars` not yet loaded — needed for `copy-core-var`, `copy-var`, `macrofy`, `new-var`
2. `sci.impl.resolve`, `sci.impl.cljs`, `sci.impl.multimethods`, `sci.impl.deftype` not yet loaded
3. Multi-arity function dispatch edge cases in utils (forms 36-37, 44-45)
4. ~9 remaining eval failures across namespaces (5) and sci.core (4) — all tracing back to missing deps
## Key patterns
@ -58,6 +64,8 @@ description: TDD workflow for bootstrapping a Clojure interpreter on Janet
### Reader conditional `#?`
Resolves at read time: scans for `:clj` keyword, picks next form.
`#?@` wraps resolved form in `:jolt/splice` struct for list/vec/set splicing.
Nil results (e.g. `#?(:cljs X)` on CLJ) now return `{:jolt/type :jolt/skip}` for non-splicing
and `{:jolt/type :jolt/splice :items @[]}` for splicing — preventing orphaned keys in maps.
### Callable forms check
```janet
@ -66,6 +74,13 @@ Resolves at read time: scans for `:clj` keyword, picks next form.
(get f (first args))) ; table/struct lookup
```
### unwrap-meta-name helper
Recursively unwraps `(with-meta sym meta)` to extract the underlying symbol.
Used in `def`, `ns`, `deftype`, `defmethod` to handle metadata-wrapped names.
### deftype →TypeName constructor
`deftype` interns both `TypeName` and `->TypeName` (Clojure arrow constructor convention).
## Pitfalls
- Janet `let` can't bind to nil; use `(var x nil)` then `(set x val)`
- `(get table)` with 1 arg = compile error, use `(table :key)` shorthand
@ -76,7 +91,8 @@ Resolves at read time: scans for `:clj` keyword, picks next form.
- **`core-macro-names`** is a zero-arg fn returning a table: `(get (core-macro-names) name)`. Don't call it as `(core-macro-names name)` — that's arity mismatch
- **Janet `#{}` sets** can cause parse issues — use `@[]` instead for stub collections
- **`break` in `while`** doesn't return a value in Janet — use `(var done nil)` + `(while (and cond (not done)) ... (set done result))` pattern instead
- **`read-reader-conditional`** for `#?(:cljs X)` with no `:clj` branch returns `[nil new-pos]`. For `#?@(:cljs X)` wrapping, nil gets wrapped in splice struct with `@[nil]` items
- **`#_` discard** now works in lists, vectors, and sets — wraps the skipped form in `{:jolt/type :jolt/skip}` and readers check for this
- **`read-regex`** now works with `(var done nil)` pattern to return value from while loop
- **`#?@` splicing inside vectors** — if the resolved :clj branch is itself a vector, items are extracted and spliced. Works for both lists and vectors.
- **`(last string)` returns nil** — `last` works only on indexed types. Use `(s (- (length s) 1))` for last char of string
- **`(set [a b] tuple)` doesn't work** — Janet's `set` doesn't support destructuring. Use `(tuple 0)` / `(tuple 1)`
- **`#_` discard** works in lists, vectors, sets, and maps — wraps skipped form in `{:jolt/type :jolt/skip}` and readers check for this
- **Map reader** must handle `:jolt/skip` and `:jolt/splice` in both key and value positions
- **`comment` macro** must be registered in `core-macro-names` to avoid evaluating its body